Hand history - what did he have ?

[Oz Poker]

Okay this is a real hand history from a $20/20 game at Pokerroom a while back.

This was the biggest game going on Pokerroom that night and I had slowly built my stack over a couple of hours when this hand came up.

Hero (me) is pitz555, villian is BlackKitty. I had this player pegged as a solid player who generally outplayed his opponents after the flop and was playing a wide range of hands as the rest of the table was fairly tight.

What did he have ?

Texas Hold'em $20-$20 NL (real money), hand #336,431,183
Table Beaumont, 8 Apr 2006 12:51 AM
View Previous | Next hand for this table.
Seat 1: Madhatr x ($2,049.50 in chips)
Seat 2: Terminater25 ($2,005.50 in chips)
Seat 3: pitz555 [5S,2S] ($4,890.75 in chips)
Seat 4: robert1mm ($1,408.10 in chips)
Seat 5: ffttdd ($5,041.35 in chips)
Seat 6: gabeto6 ($925 in chips)
Seat 8: -BlackKitty- ($3,044.50 in chips)
Seat 9: tommy rouge ($3,068.10 in chips)
Seat 10: StupidGuy x ($2,000 in chips)
ANTES/BLINDS
tommy rouge posts blind ($10), StupidGuy x posts blind ($20).

PRE-FLOP
Madhatr x calls $20, Terminater25 folds, pitz555 calls $20, robert1mm calls $20, ffttdd calls $20, gabeto6 folds, -BlackKitty- bets $100, tommy rouge folds, StupidGuy x folds, Madhatr x calls $80, pitz555 calls $80, robert1mm folds, ffttdd folds.

FLOP [board cards 5H,3S,7H ]

Madhatr x checks, pitz555 bets $300, -BlackKitty- calls $300, Madhatr x folds.

TURN [board cards 5H,3S,7H,JC ]

pitz555 bets $475, -BlackKitty- bets $1,500, pitz555 bets $2,300, -BlackKitty- calls $1,144.50 and is all-in.

RIVER [board cards 5H,3S,7H,JC,AS ]


I'll put $20 in to anyones account who can correctly guess the villian's hand.

[borgsta]

2H-4H, was going to say 4-6 but that seems to easy.

I wanna know why you called her reraise with such a low pair.

[Oz Poker]

Normally you would just throw it away but I was pretty sure they weren't holding an over pair and in a rasied pot it was serisouly unlikely that that flop had hit anyone but me. Unless perhaps they were holding A-7 - maybe A-5. My turn bet smacked of weakness and the big pot bet by the villian was an unlikely way to play the hand if they had me covered - a simple call or smaller reraise would have had me more worried. I felt the villian was just making a play for the pot.

I was fairly sure I still had the best hand at this point as wasn't prepared throw it in on an overbet.

The question is though - was I right ?